This post may contain affiliate links. By browsing this website, you agree to our disclaimer, privacy policy, and terms of use.

Finding the perfect DIY-non-toxic-makeup recipes can be tricky—some are absolute game-changers, while others fall flat. I tested and rated over 20 of the most popular recipes to reveal the best (and worst) options, so you don’t have to waste time or ingredients!

Text reading "I tried & tested these DIY non-toxic makeup recipes" with 6 DIY makeup recipes that were either a fail or a success.

Once I learned that the average woman applies a staggering 168 different chemicals a day – in just one single day – I became an even bigger fan of all-natural, non-toxic makeup. 

But sometimes, the ingredient lists on even the cleanest beauty brands can get long and unwieldy. 

Since I like to avoid the toxic ingredients in skincare and know exactly what’s going on around my skin, I thought I would try making my own natural makeup. And wow! Making your own makeup is both incredibly rewarding and surprisingly challenging. 

Before we dive into the DIY-non-toxic-makeup-recipes, there are a few things you should know: 

  • First, this journey requires precise measurements and careful sterilization – more than you might expect. 
  • While you won’t exactly recreate your favorite store-bought products (those natural ingredients just behave differently!), you can create effective, safe alternatives that work with your skin, not against it.

In this guide, I’ll walk you through everything I’ve learned from testing over 20 different DIY-non-toxic-makeup-recipes.

From foundations and blushes to mascaras and bronzers, I’ll share what worked, what didn’t, and most importantly – why. 

I’ve rated each recipe on a scale of 1-10 and included tips I discovered along the way, so you can learn from both my successes and mistakes.

So let’s head to the kitchen for some fun with DIY makeup!

Why Making Your Own Makeup Can Be A Great Idea

While making your own cosmetics can come with its own set of challenges, there are a lot of great reasons to give it a try! 

Complete Control Over Ingredients

One of the biggest advantages of making your own makeup is having total control over the ingredients you use. 

You can carefully select each component, ensuring that you’re only putting the highest-quality, most beneficial ingredients on your skin. 

It’s almost like creating a hybrid between skincare and makeup – you can incorporate antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals that nourish your skin while giving you a flawless finish. 

Customization to Suit Your Needs

Whether you’re looking to create the perfect foundation shade that seamlessly matches your skin tone or you want to adjust the texture and finish of your products based on the season, making your own makeup gives you the freedom to experiment and tweak until you find your ideal formulations.

The ability to customize is especially valuable if you have sensitive skin or allergies to specific ingredients, as you can avoid potential irritants and create products tailored to your skin’s needs. 

Better For The Environment

By creating your own products, you can significantly reduce your beauty routine’s packaging waste and overall carbon footprint. 

Instead of accumulating countless plastic containers or purchasing products that have been shipped from across the globe, you can opt for reusable or recyclable packaging and source ingredients locally when possible.

Getting Started – Essential Ingredients, Tools, & Important Safety Tips

Hopefully, by now, you’re excited about the idea of creating your own non-toxic, DIY natural makeup. However, it’s time for a little dose of reality. 

Making your own makeup requires a bit of effort and investment. But it can be worth it!

Most recipes need some specialized equipment, and the process demands attention to detail. This includes ensuring that all your tools and containers are thoroughly sterilized to prevent introducing unwanted bacteria and microbes into your makeup. 

Here’s a quick beginner’s guide on what you’ll need to get started. 

Essential Ingredients 

Always opt for the highest quality ingredients available. Look for pure, organic, and minimally processed ingredients that are sustainably sourced and ethically harvested. 

Base Ingredients

  • Arrowroot Powder: A fine, white powder that serves as the primary base for many powder products, providing a smooth, silky texture.
  • Kaolin Clay: Known for its oil-absorbing properties, it helps create a matte finish in both powder and cream formulations.
  • Rice Powder: Prized for its ultra-fine texture, it lends a soft, velvety feel to your creations.
  • Cornstarch: Another oil-absorbing ingredient that helps keep your makeup in place and prevents shine.

Natural Binders and Emulsifiers

  • Beeswax: Provides structure, helps products adhere to the skin, and offers water resistance.
  • Candelilla Wax: A vegan alternative to beeswax, perfect for those following a plant-based lifestyle.
  • Cocoa Butter: Rich and nourishing, it adds structure while providing deep moisture.
  • Shea Butter: Known for its creamy texture, it leaves skin feeling soft and supple.

Oils and Moisturizers

  • Jojoba Oil: Mimics the skin’s natural sebum, making it an excellent choice for all skin types.
  • Argan Oil: Packed with vitamins and antioxidants, it nourishes the skin without clogging pores.
  • Aloe Vera Gel: This water-based moisturizer soothes and hydrates the skin without adding excess oil.
  • Vitamin E Oil: Nourishes the skin and acts as a natural preservative.

Natural Pigments

Essential Tools & Equipment

Double Boiler Setup: Essential for gently melting and combining ingredients without damaging their beneficial properties. You can create one by placing a heat-safe glass or stainless steel bowl over a pot of simmering water. Never use direct heat, as this can degrade delicate ingredients.

Dedicated Spice Grinder: This is crucial for achieving the fine, smooth powders needed for professional-looking results. Keep this grinder separate from any food preparation to avoid cross-contamination.

Precise Measuring Tools: Accuracy is key in DIY makeup. You’ll need:

Mixing Tools to Invest in:

Containers

  • Glass Containers: Ideal for storing cosmetics due to their non-porous nature, lack of reactivity with ingredients, and ability to be thoroughly sterilized.
  • Stainless Steel Containers: Suitable for products like balms and solid perfumes, offering durability and ease of cleaning.
  • Dark-Colored Glass Containers: These are particularly beneficial for protecting light-sensitive ingredients like oils and natural pigments from degradation caused by exposure to light.
The 45 Best Non-Toxic Beauty Swaps In 2025

→ Sterilization! The Most Important Safety Step ←

***If you take anything away from this article, let it be that proper sterilization is a non-negotiable when making your own makeup.***

Failing to properly sterilize your stirring utensils, measuring tools, and containers can introduce bacteria and other microbes into your homemade makeup. 

Since these DIY recipes lack the toxic preservatives and antimicrobials found in commercial products, they are particularly vulnerable to contamination, which can lead to the growth of skin-damaging microbes.

How To Sterilize Your Equipment 

Initial Cleaning

  • Wash all tools and containers thoroughly with hot, soapy water
  • Rinse multiple times to remove all soap residue
  • Dry completely with a clean, lint-free cloth

Sterilization Methods

For Heat-Safe Glass & Metal:

  • Boil in water for 10 minutes
  • Use tongs to remove items
  • Place on a clean paper towel to air dry

For Heat-Sensitive Items:

  • Soak in 70% rubbing alcohol for 10 minutes
  • Air dry completely on a clean surface

For Work Surfaces:

  • Clean thoroughly with a disinfectant solution
  • Cover with a fresh paper towel before each use

Remember To Always

  • Keep sterilized tools separate from unsterilized ones
  • Re-sterilize tools between different products
  • Never double-dip tools into ingredients
  • Always work with clean hands or wear gloves

While making your own makeup requires some initial effort and investment, the benefits to your skin, wallet, and the environment make it totally worthwhile. 

Plus, there’s something incredibly satisfying about creating your own perfect shade of lip gloss or foundation that’s actually good for your skin.

Text reading "I tried & tested these DIY non-toxic foundation recipes" with 2 DIY foundation recipes that were either a fail or a success.

Best DIY Non-Toxic Foundation Recipes

1. Mineral Foundation Recipe

10 out of 10 | From Wellness Mama  

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This was the first DIY makeup recipe I tried, and I was pleasantly surprised by how well it wore.

It nicely blurred my pores and imperfections without creasing or settling into fine lines. It looked great and stayed on after all-day wear.

You can wear this powder foundation on its own or over your liquid foundation for extra staying power. The mica powder adds a nice, imperceptible radiance.

Note: Kelp powder is great for olive skin tones or those with yellow undertones. Banana or sea buckthorn powder is great for helping to neutralize the powder. Adding a small pinch of beetroot powder makes for a more natural skin tone.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Start with arrowroot powder as your base.
  2. Gradually add cocoa powder until you reach the desired color. Start slowly and add as needed, testing on the inner arm.
  3. Once you’ve reached your desired color, add mica, kaolin clay, or translucent mica.
  4. Store in a small glass jar with a lid and apply with a fluffy powder brush.

2. Simple Powder Foundation

10 out of 10 

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This powder foundation also turned out to be a great success, and I love how it smells!

It has a more natural, skin-toned pigment and can easily be adjusted to be a tad darker for summertime. It’s quick to make and looks great on the skin.

I highly recommend this foundation; however, I left out the cloves because I don’t particularly like the smell, and it didn’t do much to the overall pigment of the powder.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Start with 2 tablespoons of arrowroot powder and 1 tablespoon of green clay (optional).
  2. Add spices little by little, testing shades on the back of your hand as you go.
  3. Record amounts added of each spice for future batches.
  4. Store in a sterilized powder-sifter jar.

Worst DIY Non-Toxic Foundation Recipes

3. DIY Liquid Foundation 

2 out of 10 | The recipe is inspired by Savvy Homemade with swaps made for more natural and accessible ingredients

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

Trying to make this liquid foundation was a mess from start to finish. To be fair, the original recipe calls for metal oxides, which I wanted to avoid.

I’m sure this recipe would have worked better if I had used metal oxides, but when opting for natural ingredients, the overall tone was much too yellow.

Swapping turmeric for kelp powder did help tone down the yellow, but even when I got the pigment right, the texture and application just didn’t work.

The pigments sit on top of the skin, giving a chalky look rather than melting into the skin.

If you’re after a good DIY liquid foundation, I recommend using the powdered foundations above and adding them to your favorite moisturizer or face oil for a liquid application.

Pigment Ingredients

Water & Oil Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Grind pigments (zinc oxide, turmeric powder, and beetroot powder) together in a coffee grinder for 30 seconds.
  2. In a small bowl, dissolve konjac powder in glycerin.
  3. Mix rose hydrosol with the glycerin-konjac mixture.
  4. In a separate heat-safe container, combine argan oil, sunflower oil, and beeswax. Heat in a water bath until the beeswax is fully melted. It will take a little while for the beeswax to melt completely.
  5. Add the ground pigments and cornstarch to the warm oil mixture, stirring well to combine.
  6. Slowly whisk the water mixture (hydrosol, glycerin, and konjac) into the oil and pigment mixture, stirring continuously to create an emulsion.
  7. Allow the mixture to cool below 40°C (104°F).
  8. Add vitamin E oil and stir to incorporate.
  9. Transfer the foundation to a serum bottle or squeeze container.
Text reading "I tried & tested these DIY non-toxic complexion recipes" with 2 DIY complexion recipes that were either a fail or a success.

Best DIY Non-Toxic Complexion Recipes

4. Basic Makeup Primer

6 out of 10

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This was fine, but do not use coconut oil in this primer. In cold weather, it will firm up and just sit on top of the spray. Be sure to shake well before applying.

The aloe vera juice and sweet almond oil do provide some nice light hydration that helps your makeup go on more smoothly. 

Ingredients

Instructions

  • Mix all ingredients together.
  • Pour into a spray bottle and shake.
  • Spray the face with one or two layers.
  • Best used on freshly washed face.

5. Sea Buckthorn Setting Powder

5 out of 10 | Adapted recipe from @NuworldBotanicals to simplify 

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

While there is nothing inherently wrong with this recipe, I just didn’t find it was something I would go to the extra effort to make again. I got all of the same benefits from the powder foundations.

However, this is a great option for brightening your under-eye area or keeping your foundation in place during hot/humid summer months.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Add arrowroot powder as your base.
  2. Gradually add Australian beige clay, sea buckthorn powder, and banana powder 1 pinch at a time until the desired color is reached.
  3. Once combined, pour all ingredients into a spice grinder to create a fine powder and combine thoroughly.
  4. Store in a sterilized powder sifter jar.
  5. Apply with a loose powder brush over the foundation or concealer.
Top 10 Non Toxic Makeup Brands | Clean Beauty Made Easy

Worst DIY Non-Toxic Complexion Recipes

6. Non-Nano Zinc Oxide Concealer

4 out of 10 | From @ItsOrim

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This was another difficult recipe to get just right.

It tends to sit on top of the skin rather than melting in for a natural finish, perhaps because of the zinc oxide.

However, it does offer some SPF protection.

This formulation is probably best for brightening your under-eyes, but I wouldn’t recommend it for covering blemishes, as it can actually draw more attention to them since it sits on top of the skin. It does help reduce redness, though!

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Blend turmeric, cacao, and beetroot powder together in a spice grinder until completely smooth (do not add the zinc oxide powder to your spice grinder!).
  2. To a medium-sized clean bowl, carefully add your zinc oxide powder (wear a mask).
  3. Carefully add the ground mixture of turmeric, cacao, and beetroot powder to zinc oxide.
  4. Slowly mix to prevent any dust from going into the air.
  5. Next, melt the oil-based ingredients (cocoa butter, beeswax, jojoba oil, vitamin E oil, argan oil, sunflower oil) using a double boiler. Heat slowly.
  6. Slowly pour melted wax and oils over pigmented powders.
  7. Add aloe vera gel and mix to combine.
  8. Before the solution has cooled, pour it into an airtight container.
Text reading "I tried & tested these DIY non-toxic eyeshadow recipes" with 2 DIY eyeshadow recipes that were either a fail or a success.

Best DIY Non-Toxic Eyeshadow Recipes

7. Golden Brown Eyeshadow

8 out of 10

best non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

The mica powder makes this eyeshadow look really pretty, but you can get the same effect by simply mixing cocoa powder or kelp powder with mica and applying it directly to your eyelid.

Ingredients

Instructions

Mix all ingredients thoroughly and apply. Store in an airtight container.

8. Cocoa Eyeshadow

8 out of 10

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This is a pretty, basic brown. Easy to make and blends well for a nice, neutral shadow that will make your eyes pop.

Ingredients

Instructions

Mix all ingredients thoroughly and apply. Store in an airtight container.

Worst Non-Toxic DIY Eyeshadow Recipes

9. Basic Eyeshadow Base Recipe

4 out of 10

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

The rice powder and clay tend to dull and dilute the colors while making the eyeshadow unblendable and flaky.

If you want to make an all-natural eyeshadow, I think you’re best off just applying your natural ingredient of choice directly to your eyelid and then setting it with a powder foundation.

Depending on the ingredient, be sure to blend in a spice grinder for a fine powder.

Also be careful with using spices near your eyes, because some spices like cinnamon and cloves can burn. 

If using rice flour, be sure to blend well in a spice grinder before using. Or use a finer base like arrowroot powder or tapioca powder.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Combine ingredients.
  2. Add natural pigments for color:

10. Gold Eyeshadow

2 out of 10

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This eyeshadow isn’t metallic gold, but rather a beigy yellow.

The only benefit of this recipe is that the powder formula applies relatively well, but I didn’t find this eyeshadow color particularly flattering.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. In an airtight container, mix all ingredients until thoroughly combined.
  2. Apply with an eyeshadow brush.
Text reading "I tried & tested these DIY non-toxic blush recipes" with 2 DIY blush recipes that were either a fail or a success.

Best DIY Non-Toxic Blush Recipes

11. Basic Blush Recipe For All Skin Tones

9 out of 10

best non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This blush recipe was really easy to make and actually looked really nice on the skin, giving a natural flush as if after a brisk walk in the cold.

This blush looks best on dry skin without too much moisturizer; otherwise, it can tend to streak or pill.

Base Ingredients

For Darker Skin Tone

Instructions

  1. Use the following ratios to create a blush color to your desired tone.
  2. In an airtight container, mix all ingredients until thoroughly combined.
  3. Apply with a blush brush.

12. Pale Pink Blush Recipe

9 out of 10

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This blush recipe was simple to whip up, and the results were stunning.

That said, I noticed that this light pink shade wasn’t very visible on my olive-toned skin. However, it might still come in handy as a subtle color corrector.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Use the following ratios to create a blush color to your desired tone.
  2. In an airtight container, mix all ingredients until thoroughly combined.
  3. Apply with a blush brush.

13. Mauve Blush Recipe

9 out of 10

best non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

You can tell from the ratings that the DIY blush recipes were my biggest hit!

This mauve blush is a breeze to make—it only takes 2 ingredients and 3 super-simple steps.

While the tone was a bit too light for my skin, it would be absolutely stunning on someone with a fairer complexion.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Use the following ratios to create a blush color to your desired tone.
  2. In an airtight container, mix all ingredients until thoroughly combined.
  3. Apply with a blush brush.

14. Sweet & Simple DIY Strawberry Blush 

9 out of 10 (with adjustments)

best non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This was my favorite blush recipe with one major caveat – switch the strawberry powder for beetroot or hibiscus powder.

The strawberry powder is sticky, and the tackiness doesn’t feel nice on the skin. I also felt that the beetroot powder gave a more natural flush.

I like mixing this blush with my face oil for a sheer, natural application and more staying power.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Add beetroot powder to a spice grinder to ensure the powders are finely ground.
  2. Add arrowroot powder gradually to lighten (if desired).
  3. Transfer to a small bowl and ensure all clumps are gone and powders are well incorporated.
  4. Transfer to a small container with a tight-fitting lid.

Application Tips

  • Use a soft makeup brush.
  • Apply to the apples of your cheeks with an upward sweeping motion.
  • Build color gradually for desired intensity.
  • Setting spray like rose hydrosol will help keep blush in place all day.

Customization Options

  • For a darker shade: Add a pinch of cocoa powder.
  • For a brighter shade: Increase berry or beet powder slightly.

15. Deep Mauve Blush Recipe

9 out of 10

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipe guide

I absolutely adored this deep mauve blush!

Its rich, dark rose hue was perfect and blended beautifully with my olive-toned skin.

If you have a similar skin tone, this is an absolute must-try

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Use the following ratios to create a blush color to your desired tone.
  2. In an airtight container, mix all ingredients until thoroughly combined.
  3. Apply with a blush brush.
Text reading "I tried & tested these DIY non-toxic mascara recipes" with 2 DIY mascara recipes that were either a fail or a success.

Best DIY Non-Toxic Mascara Recipes

16. No Heat DIY Mascara 

5 out of 10 | Recipe from @_hollistic

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipe guide

While still not great, this option was the closest I came to making a classic mascara formula.

I was surprised since there is no wax in this formula. However, while this will add some color to your lashes, there isn’t anything to hold the color to your lashes, and it will flake and smear.

The original recipe called for lavender essential oil, which I left out since I was worried it would irritate my eyes.

I highly recommend sticking with non-toxic store bought mascara options.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Start by mixing the aloe vera gel and vegetable glycerin in a medium bowl to combine well.
  2. For best results, place bentonite clay and activated charcoal in a spice grinder to create a smooth powder and combine well.
  3. Add the bentonite clay and activated charcoal to the aloe vera and glycerin mixture.
  4. Using a syringe, place the mascara mixture into a mascara tube and apply as normal; no waiting necessary.

Worst Non-Toxic DIY Mascara Recipes

17. Customizable Mascara Recipe

2 out of 10

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipe guide

This recipe creates more of a gel-like consistency, and while it does adhere to the spoolie brush and your eyelashes, it just looks really strange on.

Heat gently, or the aloe vera gel will separate from the coconut oil and beeswax. If it does separate, take off the heat and continue to stir; the mixture should come back together.

This formula really has no staying power, and it disappeared from my lashes within an hour.

Whether you prefer jet black, a more natural black, or brown mascara, you can use this recipe to customize your mascara to create exactly the color you want.

You could even combine cacao powder with beetroot powder to create a magenta mascara that nicely highlights brown and hazel eyes.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Heat coconut oil, aloe vera gel, and beeswax in a double boiler until melted.
  2. Stir in chosen pigments.
  3. Transfer to a clean mascara tube.
  4. Chill in the fridge for a couple of hours before using.

18. Three Ingredient DIY Mascara Recipe 

2 out of 10

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipe guide

If you’re in a pinch and need to whip up some mascara real quick, this is a super simple recipe.

Just be forewarned that this option isn’t great if you’ll be out in the rain, live in a humid area, or are prone to watery eyes since there is no binder or wax in the recipe, and it is prone to smear.  

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. In a small bowl, mix the aloe vera gel and vitamin E oil until well combined.
  2. Open the activated charcoal capsules and add the powder to the mixture, or measure out about 1/2 teaspoon of activated charcoal powder.
  3. Stir thoroughly until you have a smooth, even consistency with no visible lumps.
  4. Transfer the mixture to a clean, empty mascara tube or a small container.

Application

  • If using a container, dip a clean mascara wand into the mixture, wiping off excess on the sides.
  • Apply to lashes as you would regular mascara, allowing a few seconds to dry between coats.

Storage and Shelf Life

  • Keep the mascara in a cool, dry place.
  • Use within 1-2 weeks to ensure freshness and prevent bacterial growth.

19. Four Ingredient DIY Mascara

1 out of 10 | Recipe from @holisticbree

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipe guide

I had high hopes for this recipe, and initially, the consistency looks like it’s going to be a great match for natural mascara you can purchase.

However, this formula does not work in cold weather and is too waxy to adhere to the spoolie or your lashes.

Even doubling the amount of coconut oil wasn’t able to remedy the waxiness. This sets on the spoolie like a paraffin wax treatment.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. In a double boiler, start by melting the beeswax pellets.
  2. Once melted, add the coconut oil and aloe vera gel and melt to combine.
  3. Finally, add your activated charcoal powder and mix to combine.
  4. While warm, use a funnel to add the liquid mascara to a mascara tube.
  5. Let cool overnight before using.
Text reading "I tried & tested these DIY non-toxic lip gloss recipes" with 2 DIY lip gloss recipes that were either a fail or a success.

Best DIY Non-Toxic Lip Gloss Recipes

20. DIY Lip Glow Oil

10 out of 10 | Recipe from @mellysandford

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipe guide

I loved this lip glow oil. It’s so quick and easy to make and looks really pretty on.

Plus, the more I used it, the more plump and moisturized my lips became.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Blend beetroot powder in a spice grinder to ensure a fine powder.
  2. Warm castor oil in a double boiler.
  3. Stir in beetroot powder to the warm oil until combined.
  4. Pour liquid through a mesh strainer before pouring it into a glass lip gloss tube.
  5. If using, add peppermint oil directly to the lip gloss tube and shake to combine.

21. Moisturizing Lip Balm 

6 out of 10 | Recipe from @allybesse

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipe guide

Easy to make and applies nicely. I opted not to add pigment to this batch for a basic lip balm I could use at any time. Nothing bad, nothing great, just a good basic lip moisturizer. 

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Over a double boiler, melt your beeswax, shea butter, vitamin E oil, and castor oil to combine.
  2. Transfer to a glass mixing bowl.
  3. While still warm, add hibiscus powder (or pigment of choice) and stir vigorously to combine. I recommend blending the hibiscus powder in a spice grinder to ensure a fine powder.
  4. You can also leave the hibiscus powder out for a clear moisturizing lip balm.
  5. Once combined, pour into an airtight container.
  6. Store in the refrigerator to extend shelf life.

22. Strawberry Lip Gloss 

5 out of 10 | Inspired by @brickshrimp2.0 with a few tweaks for simplicity

non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipe guide

I was really excited to make my own strawberry lip gloss, but unfortunately, this recipe didn’t work out for me as is.

The strawberry powder clumped together and didn’t distribute at all.

Instead, I opted for beetroot powder, which looked really pretty on the lips, but you do need a lot of beetroot in order to get enough pigment to show up.

The base is extra moisturizing and can be used alone without any pigment at all.

Just beware that in cold weather, this hardens to the point it’s difficult to apply to your lips. You may need to heat it slightly before using it.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Use a double boiler to melt shea butter, beeswax, and sunflower oil together.
  2. Remove from the double boiler into a small glass jar.
  3. Add arrowroot powder and stir vigorously to combine (a handheld coffee mixer is great for this job).
  4. Add 1-2 drops of oregano or rosemary oil.
  5. Add your beetroot powder to tint, adding more or less to reach your desired color.
  6. Add mica powder at this time if using.
  7. While still warm, pour into an airtight container and let cool for 3-5 hours before using.
  8. Store in the refrigerator to extend shelf life.
Text reading "I tried & tested these DIY non-toxic bronzer recipes" with 2 DIY bronzer recipes that were either a fail or a success.

Best DIY Non-Toxic Bronzer Recipes

23. Cocoa Powder Homemade Bronzer 

7 out of 10

best non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This powdered bronzer was the closest I came to recreating a bronzer powder I might buy.

However, because this isn’t a pressed powder, it makes it difficult to apply with any precision, so this is a better option for a bit of all-over color rather than contouring.

I don’t recommend adding the coconut oil, since this made it more difficult to apply evenly. 

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Start with cacao powder and cornstarch as your base.
  2. Add nutmeg, cinnamon, and hibiscus powders gradually, one pinch at a time to reach your desired color.
  3. If you have dry skin, you can add 1-2 tablespoons of melted coconut oil. This will give the powder a sandier texture and provide more staying power while still moisturizing your skin.

24. Beeswax Bronzing Lotion

7 out of 10 | From @_hollistic 

best non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

After some not-so-great trial and error with the other DIY bronzing recipes, I was pleasantly surprised by this bronzing lotion.

Since we are in the colder months, I used slightly less beeswax and shea butter for a creamier texture.

This also really benefited from using an electric mixer to whip the lotion for an airier texture that was easier to apply.

Again, this is a temporary bronzer and will wash off when you come into contact with water. But it does moisturize well and looks nice on the skin.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. In a double boiler, melt beeswax, shea butter, and cocoa butter until completely melted.
  2. Cool for 3-5 minutes before adding the next ingredients.
  3. Once cooled, add avocado oil, vitamin E oil, and frankincense essential oil.
  4. Gradually add cocoa or cinnamon powder until your desired color is reached.
  5. While still warm, pour into a lotion squeeze bottle or glass jar.
  6. Let cool for 3-5 hours, or until the lotion has solidified.

Important Notes

  • This is a temporary tanner that washes off in water.
  • Best used for special events or short-term color.
  • Store in refrigerator and use within 1-2 weeks.
15 Truly Non-Toxic Nail Polish Brands (2025)

25. Black Tea Sunless Tanner 

5 out of 10 | Inspired By DIY Natural with my own additions

best non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This is one of those DIY recipes that will work in a pinch, but I wouldn’t recommend this for regular use.

The tea will give your skin a darker tint, but it’s not physically dyeing your skin, just sitting on top of your skin, so if you get it wet or rub up against anything, your tan will rub off.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Boil water and add tea bags. For a darker tan, use more tea bags (6-8) and steep longer.
  2. Steep tea for 10-15 minutes to create a dark solution.
  3. Let the tea cool completely to room temperature (about 30 minutes).
  4. Optional: Add 1 tablespoon of dark vanilla extract for a pleasant scent.

Application Tips

  • Spray evenly on the skin, blending with a makeup sponge.
  • Apply sparingly around the ears and the neck.
  • Let each layer dry before applying another.

Important Notes

  • This is a temporary tanner that washes off in water. It may also stain clothing and upholstery. 
  • Best used for special events or short-term color.
  • Store in refrigerator and use within 1-2 weeks.

Worst DIY Non-Toxic Bronzer Recipes

26. Customizable Powdered Bronzer

4 out of 10 | Inspired by The Tree Hugger with my own adjustments

best non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes

This powder bronzer didn’t seem to add any more color than the powdered foundation recipes I tried.

I highly recommend forgoing the cinnamon if you have sensitive skin, as this can tend to burn when worn on the skin too long.

I also did not have a lot of success adding the sweet almond oil for a creamier texture. It made it harder to apply this bronzer with a brush.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Start with arrowroot/cornstarch base.
  2. Add spices and colored powders gradually until the desired shade is achieved.

Pro Tips for Perfect DIY Makeup

Color Matching

Creating the perfect shade match is probably the most exciting (and sometimes challenging) part of making your own makeup. Here’s what I’ve learned:

  • Batch Test First: Start with small test batches using different ratios of pigments (yellow, red, and brown) to find your ideal foundation shade.
  • Use Natural Daylight: Always mix colors in natural daylight, as artificial lighting can be deceiving and lead to inaccurate color perceptions.
  • Test On Your Jawline: Test your foundation on your jawline and let it sit for 5-10 minutes before deciding if it’s right, as the color can change slightly as it settles.
  • Record Keeping: Keep detailed notes of your successful color combinations, as this will help you replicate that perfect shade in the future. I recommend keeping notes on your phone so you don’t lose them!

Getting the Texture Just Right

The secret to professional-quality DIY makeup lies in the texture. Here’s how to nail it:

  • For Loose Powders: If your powder feels too heavy, add more arrowroot powder in small increments until you achieve that silky-smooth feel
  • For Cream Products: The ratio of oils to waxes is crucial. More wax creates a firmer product, while more oil makes it creamier. Start with a 4:1 ratio of oils to waxes and adjust from there
  • For Liquid Foundation: Use an immersion blender for that perfectly emulsified texture – no more separation!
  • Temperature Matters: Some ingredients like shea butter can become grainy if melted at too high a temperature. Always use your double boiler and heat gently

Preservation Secrets

While commercial preservatives aren’t part of our natural makeup journey, there are effective ways to extend your products’ shelf life:

  • Antioxidant Addition: Add vitamin E oil (about 0.5% of your total recipe) to prevent oils from going rancid and extend the shelf life of your products.
  • Light Protection: Use dark glass containers for light-sensitive ingredients to prevent degradation and maintain their effectiveness.
  • Natural Preservatives: Consider adding rosemary extract or grapefruit seed extract for their natural preservative properties, which can help prevent microbial growth.
  • Use A Spatula: Keep a small spatula or spoon with each product to avoid introducing bacteria from your fingers, ensuring cleanliness and reducing contamination risk.
  • Temperature Control: Store cream products in the fridge during hot summer months to maintain their texture and prevent spoilage.

Application Tips That Make a Difference

DIY makeup sometimes needs a slightly different approach to application:

  • Cream Product Application: Warm cream products slightly between your fingers before applying to help them blend more smoothly and evenly.
  • Mineral Foundation Technique: Apply mineral foundation in thin layers using a pressing motion rather than sweeping, which helps achieve a more uniform coverage.
  • Powder Blending: Store a small spray bottle of rose water nearby and use a light mist to help powder products blend seamlessly into your skin, creating a natural finish.
  • Cream Blush Application: Try applying cream blushes with a damp makeup sponge for the most natural-looking finish and enhanced color payoff.

Troubleshooting Like a Pro

Even experienced DIY makeup makers run into issues sometimes. Here are solutions to common problems:

  • Foundation separating? Try increasing your emulsifier ratio slightly
  • Are powders too dusty? Add a tiny bit of jojoba oil to your mineral mix
  • Is the color too intense? Don’t start over – just add more base ingredients to dilute
  • Product too soft? Pop it in the fridge for 30 minutes, then remelt with a bit more wax
  • Lipstick breaking? Your ratio of wax to oils might be too low

Small Batch Success Guidelines

One of the biggest secrets to successful DIY makeup isn’t about the ingredients or techniques – it’s about making the right amount. 

Here’s why small batches are your best friend when it comes to making your own natural cosmetics.

Why Small Batches Are So Important

When I first started making my own makeup, I was tempted to make large batches to save time. Big mistake! Here’s why small batches are crucial:

  • Natural products lack the strong preservatives found in commercial makeup, so they have a shorter shelf life.
  • Making smaller amounts lets you experiment with formulas without wasting ingredients.
  • Your skin’s needs might change with the seasons, so smaller batches allow you to adapt your formulas.
  • Fresh ingredients mean better performance and safer products for your skin.

Calculating Perfect Amounts

Getting your quantities right takes a bit of planning, but I promise it’s worth it:

  • Start by tracking how long your current makeup products last.
  • Consider your daily usage – foundation tends to run out faster than blush.
  • Factor in the product’s shelf life once opened.
  • Always include a small buffer amount for accidents or special occasions.

My Tried-and-True Formula

  • Daily usage amount × Days until expiration = Batch size
  • Add 10% extra for a safety buffer
  • Round up to the nearest practical measuring amount

For Example:

  • Foundation: If you use 0.5g daily and want it to last 30 days
  • 0.5g × 30 days = 15g
  • Add 10% (1.5g) = 16.5g
  • Round up to 17g total batch size

Safely Storing Your DIY Natural Makeup

Proper storage not only extends the shelf life of your homemade cosmetics but also prevents the growth of harmful bacteria and other contaminants. 

General Storage Tips

  • Product Labeling: Label each product with the date of creation and the ingredients used, allowing you to easily keep track of its shelf life and identify any potential allergens.
  • Environmental Protection: Keep your products away from direct sunlight and heat sources, as exposure to high temperatures can degrade the ingredients and shorten the shelf life.
  • Store In A Cool, Dry Place: Store your cosmetics in a cool, dry place, such as a bedroom drawer or closet shelf. Avoid storing them in the bathroom, where humidity levels are often high. You can even store your cosmetics in the refrigerator to prolong their life. 

Product-Specific Storage Guidelines

  • 1-2 Weeks: Products containing water (toners, mists, etc.)
  • 1-3 Months: Liquid products (foundation, eyeliner, mascara, etc.)
  • 3-6 Months: Creams and Balms (lip balm, cream blush, cream eyeshadow, etc.)
  • 6-12 Months: Powders (foundations, blush, eyeshadow, etc.)
  • 6-12 Months: Oil-based products (cleansing oils, facial oils, etc.)

It’s essential to note that these are general guidelines, and the actual shelf life of your homemade cosmetics may vary depending on the specific ingredients used, the storage conditions, and how frequently the product is opened and used. 

Always check your products for any signs of spoilage, such as changes in color, texture, or scent, and discard them if you suspect they have gone bad.

This has been your guide to the best non-toxic DIY natural makeup recipes.

After weeks of experimenting with these DIY natural makeup recipes, I’ve learned that making your own cosmetics is both an art and a science. 

While not every recipe was a success (I’m looking at you, liquid foundation!) the wins were great surprises. 

The powdered foundation and lip glow oil have become staples in my daily routine, proving that natural alternatives can be just as good as store-bought options, if not better.

Here are the most valuable lessons learned:

  1. Precision is Everything: Remember those exact measurements I mentioned at the start? I wasn’t kidding! A tiny shift in ratios can transform a perfect foundation into a chalky mess. Invest in a good scale and prepare to take detailed notes – your future self will thank you.
  2. Sterilization Is Non-Negotiable: I can’t stress this enough. Proper sterilization is so important for protecting your skin. Yes, it takes extra time, but it’s worth it in the long run.
  3. Natural Pigments Can Be Tricky: While you might not achieve that perfect skin match, natural pigments like beetroot and cocoa powder can create beautiful, skin-enhancing colors that look incredibly natural. The key is working with their properties rather than fighting against them and taking time to adjust ratios as needed.
  4. Start Small And Be Prepared To Experiment: My most successful experiments came from starting with small batches and adjusting the formulas based on results. This not only saves money but allows you to perfect your recipes without waste.
  5. Not All DIY Makeup Is Worth The Effort: In the end, I don’t think DIY mascara is worth the effort. With so many great non-toxic mascara options out there, I say save you time and money and purchase a mascara that you know will work every time. 

Yes, there’s a learning curve, and yes, you’ll probably have a few mishaps along the way.

But whether you’re looking to replace your entire makeup collection or just experiment with a few natural alternatives, I hope this guide gives you the confidence to start your own DIY beauty journey.

Your first attempts might not be perfect, but each attempt teaches you something new about what works for your skin. 

And isn’t that what beauty is really about – finding what works best for you?

Check out our other amazing Non-Toxic Cosmetics articles:

Like It? Pin It!

Text reading "I tried & tested these DIY non-toxic makeup recipes" with 6 DIY makeup recipes that were either a fail or a success.

Jenna is a former marketing consultant for pharmaceutical corporations with a background in biology. She was diagnosed with an auto-immune condition in her early 20s, which led her on a journey to understand the root causes of her condition. The more she researched, the more she discovered the numerous health-harming chemicals we expose ourselves to every day. She realized that these chemicals have a direct impact on our long-term health. Now, she empowers readers to make healthier and more sustainable choices by encouraging them to be more conscious of the products they bring into their homes!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Similar Posts