15 Low-Tox & Non-Toxic Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

What is non-toxic mascara?

Unlike conventional mascaras that often contain harmful ingredients like parabens, phthalates, and synthetic fragrances, non-toxic mascaras are made with cleaner, gentler ingredients that prioritize your eye health without compromising on performance.

Non-toxic mascaras use naturally derived ingredients, like nourishing oils and plant-based waxes, to condition and strengthen your lashes while providing the same lengthening, volumizing, and curling effects you love. 

Non-toxic mascaras undergo rigorous testing to ensure they’re free of known toxic ingredients, making them a safer choice for your delicate eye area.

What certifications should I look for when shopping for a non-toxic mascara?

USDA Organic

If a mascara is USDA Certified Organic, it means that at least 95% of its ingredients are organic, and the remaining 5% must be approved by the USDA.

This certification ensures that the product is free of synthetic chemicals, pesticides, and GMOs.

COSMOS Organic and Natural

COSMOS is a European certification that guarantees the product is made with organic and natural ingredients.

For a mascara to be COSMOS Organic certified, at least 95% of the agriculturally derived ingredients must be organic, and for COSMOS Natural certification, at least 95% of the ingredients must be natural or derived from natural sources.

MADE SAFE

The MADE SAFE seal indicates that a product has been thoroughly screened for known harmful ingredients and is free of toxins that can harm human health and the environment.

NSF/ANSI 455-3

The NSF/ANSI 455-3 certification, also known as the NSF Cosmetics and Personal Care Product Certification, ensures that a product has been independently verified to meet strict standards for quality, safety, and sustainability. 

This certification also verifies that the product is free from harmful levels of contaminants and that the manufacturer follows good manufacturing practices.

Non-toxic mascara vs. conventional mascara – is it worth it?

One of the biggest concerns about non-toxic mascaras is whether they can deliver the same results as conventional formulas.

The good news is that today’s non-toxic mascaras have come a long way in terms of performance.  Many clean mascaras offer impressive lengthening, volumizing, and curling effects that rival drugstores and luxury brands. 

When it comes to longevity and wear time, non-toxic mascaras can hold their own. While some may require a touch-up throughout the day, many clean formulas offer long-lasting, smudge-proof wear that keeps your lashes looking great from morning to night.

As for price point, it’s true that some non-toxic mascaras can be more expensive than drugstore brands. However, the difference in cost is often reflective of the high-quality, clean ingredients used in the formulas. 

And there are so many non-toxic options available at different price points, there’s a clean mascara out there for every budget.

What are some tips for choosing the best non-toxic mascara?

Identify Your Lash Goals

Volume: Look for mascaras that boast a “volumizing” or “thickening” effect. These usually contain ingredients like beeswax or plant-based waxes that help coat each lash for a fuller look.   

Length: If you desire longer lashes, seek mascaras labeled as “lengthening.” They often have fibers that adhere to your lashes, creating the illusion of added length.   

Curl: For those with straight lashes, a “curling” mascara can help hold a curl throughout the day. These usually have a curved wand and a formula designed to set the shape.   

Assess Your Sensitivity Level

Sensitive Eyes: If your eyes are easily irritated, opt for mascaras specifically formulated for sensitive eyes. They generally exclude common irritants like fragrances, parabens, and sulfates.   

Contact Lens Wearers: Choose mascaras that are safe for contact lens wearers. These tend to be less likely to flake or smudge, minimizing the risk of irritating your lenses.

Keep Your Lifestyle In Mind

Water Resistance: If you need your mascara to withstand sweat, tears, or rain, a water-resistant or waterproof formula is essential. However, remember that these can be harder to remove and may require a dedicated makeup remover.

Long-Wear: For those with busy schedules or who simply want a mascara that lasts all day, a long-wear formula can be a great option.

Remember To

• Read the ingredients list. Even with organic and non-toxic mascaras, it’s important to review the ingredient list to ensure you’re comfortable with the components. 
• Always do a patch test. If you’re trying a new mascara brand, especially if you have sensitive skin, perform a patch test on your inner arm before applying it to your lashes to check for any reactions.
• Replace your mascara regularly. To prevent bacterial buildup, replace your mascara every 3-6 months.

What’s the best way to apply non-toxic mascara for long-lasting wear?

Application Tips 

• Prime your lashes. If you have particularly oily lids, consider lightly dusting them with a translucent powder or using an eyeshadow primer. This creates a barrier and prevents smudging.
• Wipe the wand before applying, and gently wipe the excess mascara off the wand onto a tissue. This helps to avoid clumping.   
• Less is more. Apply thin coats and build up gradually for your desired effect. Too much mascara at once can lead to smudging and flaking.
• Avoid pumping the wand. Pumping the wand introduces air into the tube, which can dry out the mascara and shorten its lifespan. Instead, gently swirl the wand inside the tube to pick up the product.   
• Store your mascara properly. Keep the mascara tightly closed when not in use and avoid exposing it to extreme temperatures.

Application Techniques

• Wiggle and roll. Start at the base of your lashes and wiggle the wand back and forth while slowly rolling it upwards. This helps coat each lash evenly from root to tip.
• Focus on the roots. For extra volume, concentrate the mascara at the roots of your lashes and lightly feather it upwards.
• Use a lash comb. If you experience clumping, gently run a lash comb through your lashes while the mascara is still wet to separate them.   
• Don’t forget the lower lashes, Lightly coat your lower lashes with mascara for a complete look. Use a smaller wand or the tip of the main wand for more precise application.

Application Tips for Sensitive Eyes

• Ensure your lashes are clean and free of any makeup residue or oils before applying mascara. Use a gentle, fragrance-free cleanser.
• If you use eye cream, allow it to fully absorb before applying mascara. This helps prevent smudging and irritation.
• Choose a hypoallergenic formula. Opt for mascaras specifically designed for sensitive eyes. Look for those that are fragrance-free, paraben-free, and ophthalmologist-tested.
• Always do a patch test on your inner arm before applying a new mascara to your lashes, even if it’s labeled as hypoallergenic.
• Apply a thin layer of mascara to your upper lashes, focusing on the roots. Avoid applying too much mascara too close to the lash line, as this can irritate sensitive eyes.
• Use a clean mascara wand or a disposable spoolie brush to gently separate any clumps and remove excess mascara.
• Avoid rubbing. If you need to remove any smudges, use a cotton swab dipped in a gentle makeup remover and gently dab the area. Avoid rubbing or pulling on your lashes.

What’s the best way to remove non-toxic mascara?

To remove non-toxic mascara gently, soak a cotton pad with oil-based or micellar water remover and hold it over your closed eye for a few seconds. This allows the mascara to break down, making it easier to gently wipe away.

Be sure to choose products designed for sensitive eyes and avoid harsh ingredients. Cleansing your face afterward with a mild cleanser ensures all residue is gone. Reusable makeup remover pads offer a sustainable alternative to disposable cotton pads. 

For a smoother removal process, use lukewarm water and be patient to avoid irritation. Don’t forget to cleanse your eyelids and apply a gentle eye cream afterward to hydrate and soothe the delicate eye area. 

How can I extend the life of my non-toxic mascara?

Tightly Close the Tube: After each use, make sure to screw the cap on tightly to prevent air from getting in and drying out the mascara.

Avoid Pumping the Wand: Pumping the wand in and out of the tube introduces air, which can dry out the formula and lead to clumping. Instead, gently swirl the wand inside the tube to pick up the product.

Store in a Cool, Dry Place: Avoid storing your mascara in direct sunlight or in humid areas like the bathroom. Extreme temperatures can affect the formula and shorten its lifespan.

Clean the Wand Regularly: Wipe the wand with a clean tissue after each use to remove any excess mascara and prevent clumps from forming.

Don’t Share: Sharing mascara can introduce bacteria and lead to eye infections. It’s best to keep your mascara for personal use only.

Replace Regularly: Even with proper care, mascara has a limited shelf life. It’s generally recommended to replace your mascara every 3-6 months to avoid bacterial buildup and ensure optimal performance.